Site Meter Fiction Scribe » Blog Archive » Pet Peeve #50 - Undeveloped Magic Systems

Pet Peeve #50 - Undeveloped Magic Systems

by
pet-peeves.jpg

Last Friday on The Book Stacks I reviewed Jim Melvin’s The Pit, first book of The Death Wizard Chronicles. One of the things that most impressed me about his adult fantasy book is the magic system he has set up.

See, what Melvin has done is created a magic system that has a reason. It exists and works above and beyond the people who access it. Only certain people can get access to this power, the power runs out and the wielder needs to recharge occasionally, and the magic exists as part of a system.

Nothing is more annoying than having magic in a book that is merely there for the sake of making characters powerful. Yay, I can shoot lightning from my fingertips! Why? Where does the lightning come from? Why can you do it and Joe over there can’t? Why do you shoot lightning and Amy shoots fire? What makes you two different?

Those are the questions you need to ask and know the answers to before you run around giving every other character the ability to fly. Even the Fantastic Four were hit by some cosmic rays of some type or another. Spiderman was bitten by a spider and the X-Men are just the next step of human evolution.

See? Reasons behind the magic. They don’t have magic/powers for the sake of looking cool. Reasons, systems, weaknesses, etc.

So yes, feel free to give your characters access to magic and/or powers. That’s perfectly fine unless you don’t give a reason for the magic/powers. You need a system. You need reasons.

Even if your readers don’t find out about each intricate detail behind your creations, you can speak (write) with the confidence that you know the ‘how’ and ‘why’ of your magic/powers.


2 Responses to “Pet Peeve #50 - Undeveloped Magic Systems”

  1. Jim Melvin Says:

    You bring up some excellent points in your essay about magic. The characters in my series who are able to wield magic and the sources of their powers are inextricably linked — both literally and figuratively. The very essence of The DW Chronicles flows from the paradox of magical origins.

  2. Jason Says:

    Nailed it.

    Magic without an underlying foundation can ruin an otherwise god story.

    I recently participated in a blog tour and I got a chance to ask an author about this.

    2x: In a lot of fantasy stories that contain magic there’s an entire system set up to explain it. Could you give us a brief overview of how magic works in Erec’s world?

    She knew how magic worked in her world. Too many writers don’t.

Leave a Reply


About Fiction Scribe

Is your spelling less than stupendous? Has getting published gone from possibility to problem? Are you alienating your readers with alliteration? Here at Fiction Scribe you can find what you need for prompts, publishing opportunities and advice, fun wordplay, and more. Use Fiction Scribe for the encouragement you love, the information you want, and pointing out the mistakes writers make that you need. Fiction Scribe: Your source for everything writing.

Fiction Scribe Author(s)

Blogging Flair

Books & Writing Channel Posts

  • A Book by Any Other Name - God(s)
    Welcome to this week’s A Book By Any Other Name! The game works like this: Each week I will choose a word and offer a few titles that I’ve come up with containing that word in the title. Then [...]
  • Saturday Poll - The New Year
    What are your writing goals for the new year?(online surveys) The funny thing is I'm pre-posting this in July. It's almost scary to be thinking about 2010... [...]
  • A Book by Any Other Name - Sign
    Welcome to this week’s A Book By Any Other Name! The game works like this: Each week I will choose a word and offer a few titles that I’ve come up with containing that word in the title. Then [...]
  • Saturday Poll - Holidays
    How are your holidays going?(poll) [...]
  • A Book by Any Other Name - Need
    Welcome to this week’s A Book By Any Other Name! The game works like this: Each week I will choose a word and offer a few titles that I’ve come up with containing that word in the title. Then [...]
  • Saturday Poll - Music
    Do you listen to music when you write?(polls) [...]
  • A Book by Any Other Name - Promise
    Welcome to this week’s A Book By Any Other Name! The game works like this: Each week I will choose a word and offer a few titles that I’ve come up with containing that word in the title. Then [...]
  • Saturday Poll - Pen Names
    Do you have/plan to have a pen name?(surveys) [...]
  • A Book by Any Other Name - Right
    Welcome to this week’s A Book By Any Other Name! The game works like this: Each week I will choose a word and offer a few titles that I’ve come up with containing that word in the title. Then [...]
  • Saturday Poll - Tis the Season
    Do you write 'seasonal' stories?(polls) [...]

Hot Off The Press